Incorrect sponge count

Operating room nurses are at high risk for being sued for an incorrect sponge count. Correct sponge counts are critical to avoid retained sponges and complications for the patient.

Can people in the operating room multitask when it comes to counting sponges? I know surgeons listen to music, talk about the stock market and their investments, and chat with the OR staff, but when it comes to safety, there is no fool-proof technology system to detect missing sponges.

Gel pads that alarm when a tagged sponge is left inside a patient, a wand that is waved over the body to scan the patient after surgery, radiofrequency tags – all have some kind of drawback.

The consequences of an incorrect sponge count 

• Panic in the operating room when the count discrepancy is announced
• Urgency to find the sponge to resolve the issue and keep the schedule on time
• Possible development of pain and adhesions from retained sponges
• Litigation for retained sponges, with cases frequently being won by plaintiffs: “get out your checkbook”
• Loss of reputation when the public becomes aware of the facility’s problem of retained items (Centers for Medicare and Medicaid started releasing the names in 2011)

Curing the problem of an incorrect sponge count

A cognitive psychologist from Minnesota, Kathleen Harder, is credited with identifying teamwork techniques to tackle the problem. These include:
1. Having a preoperative briefing during which members of the surgical team say hello to each other and exchange names
2. Counting the sponges before the case begins, rather than under the pressure at the beginning of the case.
3. Not allowing surgeons to interrupt a counting process.
4. Displaying counts on a wall-mounted board where all can see it.
5. Requiring the surgeon to announce he or she has tucked a sponge under an organ (which is noted on the board).
6. Counting performed by two people standing side by side, focused only on counting.
7. Organizing surgical items the same way in every operating room, counting them in the same order every time.

Does this work?

When University of Minnesota Medical Center and Christina Care Health System implemented these techniques, they reduced retained surgical items to zero for 154,000 surgeries.

Read ”Sponges: Beyond Counting”, HealthLeaders June 2011, page 58-59 for more information. Learn more about nursing liability for operating room roles by watching our online training, Deciphering Operating Room Nursing Liability.